Learn · rejection

Principal Contractor Rejected My Risk Assessment: What to Do Next

Getting a risk assessment bounced back is frustrating, especially when you are ready to start work. But a rejection is not a personal slight. Under the Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015 (CDM 2015), the principal contractor (PC) has to plan, manage and monitor the construction phase and coordinate health and safety across everyone working on it. Anyone appointing a contractor also has to take reasonable steps to satisfy themselves that the contractor has the skills, knowledge and experience to do the work safely. Your RAMS is how the PC evidences both of those things, which is why a weak one gets pushed back.

Understanding why yours was rejected, and what a compliant document actually looks like, is the fastest route to getting on site.


Why the Principal Contractor Can Reject Your Risk Assessment

The PC is the duty holder responsible for coordinating construction phase health and safety on site. Regulation 13 of CDM 2015 is where their duty to plan, manage, monitor and coordinate the construction phase sits, and regulation 8 is where the duty to check a contractor's skills, knowledge and experience sits. Worth knowing: CDM 2015 does not mention a RAMS anywhere. The document is the industry's way of demonstrating those duties have been met, not something the regulations name. That is why the PC sets the standard for what they will accept, and why it varies between sites.

The standard your risk assessment itself has to meet is "suitable and sufficient", which comes from regulation 3 of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999 and applies to every employer. It means the assessment must:

  • reflect the actual risks of your specific task on this specific site
  • show that risks have been reduced as far as reasonably practicable
  • be understood by the people carrying out the work

A generic, cut-and-paste document rarely passes that test.


Common Reasons for Rejection

PCs see the same problems repeatedly. Check whether your document fell into any of these categories.

Too generic. Phrases like "slips, trips and falls: wear appropriate PPE" tell nobody anything. The assessment needs to name the hazards relevant to your trade and task, the controls you will actually use, and who is responsible.

Controls jump straight to PPE. PPE sits at the bottom of the hierarchy of control for good reason. It is the last line of defence, not the primary one. If your document lists gloves and hard hats as the main control for every hazard, expect a rejection. Work through elimination, substitution, engineering controls and administrative measures first.

No site-specific information. A risk assessment written before a site visit often misses hazards such as proximity to live services, restricted access, overhead lines or public footfall. The PC knows the site; if your document ignores its conditions, they will notice.

Missing or thin method statement. A RAMS is two documents working together. The risk assessment identifies hazards and controls; the method statement sets out the sequence of work, the resources needed and how the controls will actually be applied. If the method statement is absent or consists of two sentences, that is likely part of the problem.

Unqualified competence claims. If your task requires specific training or certification (IPAF, PASMA, asbestos awareness, hot works permits, etc.) and the document does not evidence it, the PC cannot verify competence.


How to Respond to a Rejection

  1. Ask for the specific reasons in writing. A reputable PC will tell you exactly what is missing. If feedback is vague, reply by email asking them to identify the deficient sections. This also creates a clear record.

  2. Read the construction phase plan. CDM 2015 requires the PC to draw one up. It contains site-specific hazards, rules and emergency arrangements. Your RAMS should reflect it, and asking for it is entirely normal.

  3. Revisit the site or task brief before rewriting. Walk the task through in your head (or physically) and list every hazard in sequence. Work your controls down the hierarchy: can the hazard be eliminated entirely? If not, substituted? If not, controlled by engineering means (guarding, ventilation, barriers)? Administrative controls (permits, exclusion zones, training) come next. PPE comes last.

  4. Be specific about your controls. Instead of "work at height controls in place", write: "PASMA-trained operatives will erect a tower scaffold to a maximum platform height of 4 m; the working platform will be fully boarded with toe boards and double guardrails; no work will take place in wind speeds above Beaufort 5."

  5. Name the people and their competence. List the operatives, their relevant qualifications and any certificates. If you use subcontractors, their competence is your responsibility too.

  6. Resubmit with a covering note. Briefly explain what changes you have made in response to the feedback. This helps the PC review quickly and shows you engaged with their concerns rather than just reissuing the same document.


A Note on Disputes

If you believe the rejection is unreasonable and is being used to delay or disadvantage you commercially, you can raise this formally with the PC's site management or their H&S team. Keep all correspondence. In persistent cases, the HSE's general enquiries line (0300 003 1747) can advise, though they do not arbitrate commercial disputes.

That said, in practice, most rejections are genuine. A robust, specific and well-structured RAMS is the quickest way to resolve the situation and get work under way safely.


Key Points to Remember

  • CDM 2015 does not name a RAMS. The PC asks for one because it is how they evidence their duties to plan, manage and monitor the work (reg 13) and to check your skills, knowledge and experience (reg 8).
  • "Suitable and sufficient" is the legal test your risk assessment must meet, under the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999 reg 3.
  • Controls must follow the hierarchy: eliminate first, PPE last.
  • Make your assessment task-specific and site-specific every time.
  • A RAMS is a risk assessment and a method statement together. Both sections must be complete.

Getting this right first time saves everyone time and, more importantly, keeps your team safe on site.

Need the document itself?

RAMSReady generates RAMS, risk assessments, method statements, COSHH and fire risk assessments to the correct published standard, or check your existing one free.

More from the RAMSReady library