Learn · rejection

My Method Statement Was Rejected: What Do I Fix First?

Getting a method statement sent back is frustrating, especially when a start date is close. The good news is that most rejections come down to a small number of recurring problems. Work through the checks below in order and you will address the issues that account for the vast majority of returned documents.

Understand what a RAMS actually is

Before fixing anything, confirm you have the right document type. A RAMS is a Risk Assessment combined with a Method Statement: two linked documents, not one. Assessing the risks is the legal requirement, under regulation 3 of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999. Writing the assessment down is required of employers with five or more employees. Below that, the obligation to produce the document usually comes from the principal contractor or the client rather than from the law, which is why their standard is the one that matters. The method statement is the operational document that translates your findings into a safe working sequence.

If your reviewer has separated these and questioned them individually, treat each section on its own terms.

Step 1: Check whether it is actually site-specific

This is the single most common reason for rejection. A generic template with a company name dropped in will almost always fail. The principal contractor or client reviewer is looking for evidence that you have thought about their site, their sequence of works and their specific hazards.

Go through every section and ask: does this describe what we are actually doing, where we are doing it and with whom?

Things to make specific:

  • The exact location and scope (bay number, floor level, grid reference if relevant)
  • The equipment and plant you will actually use on this job
  • The number of workers and their roles
  • Any site rules, permit requirements or coordination with other trades already noted in the Construction Phase Plan (CDM 2015 applies on most construction projects)

Step 2: Check the control hierarchy

Reviewers trained to HSE standards will look at whether your controls follow the correct hierarchy. Listing PPE as your primary or only control is a very common rejection trigger.

The correct order is:

  1. Eliminate the hazard altogether
  2. Substitute for something less hazardous
  3. Engineering controls (guarding, LEV, barriers)
  4. Administrative controls (permits, supervision, training, safe systems of work)
  5. PPE as the last line of defence

If your document jumps straight to "operatives to wear hard hats and gloves", go back and ask what can be done higher up the hierarchy first. PPE can still appear, but it sits at the bottom, not the top.

Step 3: Check that hazards and controls actually match

Each identified hazard must have a corresponding control measure. A common formatting problem is a hazard list on one side and a generic control list on the other, with no clear link between them.

Check that:

  • Every hazard has at least one specific control
  • The residual risk rating (if you use one) reflects the controls you have applied, not just the initial severity
  • You have not listed a hazard and then described a control for a completely different activity

Step 4: Check competence and responsibility

Method statements must name who is responsible for what. Vague phrases like "the supervisor will ensure" mean nothing if no supervisor is named or their competence is not evidenced.

Fix this by:

  • Naming the site supervisor or responsible person by role (and name where required by the client)
  • Referencing relevant training, tickets or qualifications (IPAF, PASMA, CSCS, manufacturer training and so on)
  • Confirming that any subcontractors working under your method statement have been included and their competence verified

Step 5: Check the method statement sequence itself

The method statement section should describe the work in the order it will actually happen. Reviewers often reject documents where the sequence is illogical, skips stages or fails to describe how operatives will access, carry out and leave the work area safely.

Walk through it mentally as if you are on site. Common gaps include:

  • No isolation or permit-to-work procedure before live work begins
  • No description of how materials or waste will be handled
  • No mention of how the area will be made safe at the end of each shift

Step 6: Check emergency and welfare arrangements

Even short-duration work requires you to state what happens if something goes wrong. Many rejected documents omit:

  • First aid provision and the name of the first aider
  • Nearest hospital with an A&E (for higher-risk work)
  • Emergency contact numbers
  • Welfare facilities available on site

Step 7: Check signatures and version control

A method statement that has not been signed and dated by the author, reviewed by a competent person and issued with a clear version number gives the reviewer no confidence it is live and authorised. Add a simple document control box if you do not already have one.


A quick rejection checklist

CheckCommon fix
Is it site-specific?Remove generic text, add real site detail
Does the control hierarchy work?Move PPE to last resort
Do hazards and controls link clearly?Use a table or numbered cross-references
Are responsible persons named?Add names and qualifications
Is the method sequence logical?Rewrite in step-by-step order
Are emergency arrangements included?Add first aid, A&E, contacts
Is it signed and version-controlled?Add an authorisation box

One final point

If the rejection notice contains specific written comments from the reviewer, address every single point raised before resubmitting. Sending back a document that fixes some comments but ignores others is one of the most reliable ways to get rejected a second time. Number the reviewer's points, note how you have addressed each one and include a short covering note when you resubmit. It signals professionalism and saves everyone time.

Need the document itself?

RAMSReady generates RAMS, risk assessments, method statements, COSHH and fire risk assessments to the correct published standard, or check your existing one free.

More from the RAMSReady library